Don't Tell Comedy has built its name on secrecy—no lineup announced until you're in the room—and the All Stars edition ups the ante by pulling together some of the sharpest, most seasoned comics from its years of surprise shows. Expect a tight set of road-tested material from comedians who know how to work a crowd, delivered without the polish of a big theater or the predictability of a headliner tour.

The setting adds its own flavor to the night: On The Record, Park MGM's speakeasy-style homage to old record stores, trades the usual comedy club backdrop for a lounge built around music nostalgia and late-night cool. It's an intimate, slightly clandestine space, fitting for a show that thrives on not knowing exactly who you're about to see or what they're going to say.